James Byers, “Rape”, 30 July 1951

comments 4

In July, 1951, James Byers escaped from the hospital in Ohio where he’d been sent after being badly injured during his arrest for rape, and the Youngstown police alerted nearby towns that he might be headed their way.

On the last day of the month, residents of Cascade Street, on the eastern edge of New Castle, informed the police that a suspicious couple had “slept all night in the weeds” nearby. When Officers Bartoshek and Richards went to investigate, they identified the man as James and arrested him. They placed the couple in separate cells in city hall, holding James on a rape charge (a detail that the New Castle News delicately neglected to report) and the woman – who turned out to be James’s wife, standing by her man in his hour of need – on an open charge.

After James had his photograph taken – the very mug shot on this page – he was led back down to the cells by Andy Fair, an auxiliary constable. Fair had been a prize-fighter in the twenties but he was heading for retirement now and his muscles had long since run to fat, which no doubt influenced what James did next.

As the pair walked along a corridor in the basement of the building, James made a break for it, bursting through a door that led to the police garage and fleeing up the ramp into North Jefferson Street. He took off in the direction of Falls Street, away from the centre. Perhaps he planned to keep running until he hit the woods on the edge of town, or perhaps he had no plan at all. In any case, he managed to run only two blocks before Officer D’Ambrosia, riding one of the police bicycles that he’d been testing in the street just outside city hall, caught up with him and placed him under arrest for the second time that day.

James was sent back to Ohio. There’s no record of what happened to his wife.

Sources: New Castle News (“Freedom Dash Unsuccessful”, 31 July, 1951; Andy Fair’s boxing history and later weight gain, untitled stub, page 7, 5 November 1958.)


  1. Stuart Bartoshek says

    Awesome story and website! I’m actually Officer Bartoshek’s grandson and think its really great someone didn’t let the police just throw out all this history. Keep posting new stuff, consider me subscribed

      • Peggy Richards says

        Officer Richards was my Grandfather, Ray Lamont Richards from Winslow Avenue in New Castle!

        • Excellent! Now I only need a relative of Andy Fair, the auxiliary constable, to comment and I’ve got the full law-enforcement set! Thanks for writing, Peggy.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s